FunEnclave
 
Search 






Not a member?
Register now!



Is it so difficult to have a platonic relationship?

This is a discussion on Is it so difficult to have a platonic relationship? within the Chit Chat forums, part of the The Lounge category; I found this really nice article on MSN. I wud encourage you all to read it. Do post your views ...

Reply
> The Lounge > Chit Chat
  #1 (permalink)  
 Old 12 Apr 08, 08:05 AM
Private Ryan's Avatar
The Boogieman
 
Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.
Rep Power: 31
Nickels: 117.86
Bank: 120,561.86
   
Self Satisfied Is it so difficult to have a platonic relationship?

I found this really nice article on MSN. I wud encourage you all to read it. Do post your views about the same. Do you think it is hard for a man and a woman to have a platonic relationship? If so, why?

I put forth this question to a very good friend of mine. His answer to it is - Ideally speaking yes, but practically speaking NO. Such relationships might be possible but the percentage of it is way too minimum, to even be seen.

Can there not exist a relationship between a man and a woman that is devoid of physical desires in it? Why does the society show narrow mindedness when it sees a man and a woman together and brand their friendship as an ‘affair’ or say there sure is "something" going between the two?

Why should it mean that in a good friendship between two people, there is a hidden affair going on?

Does friendship between a man and a woman culminate only to satiate physical desires between the two? Does love between friends of opposite gender, only mean something to do with carnal cravings?

My views about a platonic relationship is not where the friends sit with each other for hours together, either face to face or chat over phone or internet and in the process neglect their family life or ignore their spouse. It is also not about a situation, where the friends feel missed if they don’t see each other or talk to each other, even for a day.

I do believe a platonic relationship between a man and a woman is possible. It is one of the sweetest friendship that one can ever experience.

If such friendship is fading away from our lives it is more so because of the possessive feeling of their spouse. The suspicious nature inherent in the spouse of the friends leads them to conceal this relationship. The fear that such a relationship can not be accepted or will be misunderstood or what the society may say, to such a friendship, which in turn affects their family life, leads them to hide this relationship. When a situation arises as to which to hold on to – family or friend, to ensure smooth running of the family, family seems to be the one they have to choose as they are committed to it. Thereby the friendship remains hidden, or nipped off in the bud stage itself.

Trust/faith/belief call it whatever you want, is the base that holds strong and tight any relationship. Marriage is based on this concrete foundation named trust. If that trust is not visible, then how can one ever lead a life with happiness and joy in it. The absence of trust makes one suspect the other in life. Injecting venom in the seeds planted will lead to the death of the plant even before the shoots show their face, the plant just withers and dies, because the venom has settled in the roots. Does the root survive? Never. Such is the disaster that is created because of venom in the form of suspicion in relationship.

Physical relationship between spouses is something that binds them together. And it is a form of expressing love between them. And in that love is the trust that they share between them. I cannot, in thoughts or deeds, imagine a person having physical relationship with someone other than their own spouse. The relationship that one shares with their spouse is totally different from those shared with friends. There is this component of
love in both the relationships. They have their own way of being expressed.

If the heart and mind is pure, the relationship is genuine, the trust is incomparable, then just seek out with sincerity in heart, one is sure to find a friendship that has only pure love in it – platonic friendship

'Tis the perception of the beautiful, A fine extension of the faculties, Platonic, universal, wonderful, Drawn from the stars, and filtered through the skies, Without which life would be extremely dull "

- Lory Byron

Last edited by Private Ryan; 12 Apr 08 at 08:09 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #2 (permalink)  
 Old 12 Apr 08, 08:26 AM
Saiyan's Avatar
The Dark Knight
 
Saiyan has passed FE Fun College with honours!Saiyan has passed FE Fun College with honours!Saiyan has passed FE Fun College with honours!Saiyan has passed FE Fun College with honours!Saiyan has passed FE Fun College with honours!Saiyan has passed FE Fun College with honours!
Send a message via MSN to Saiyan
Rep Power: 9
Nickels: 12,369.71
Bank: 42,540.96
 
Default Re: Is it so difficult to have a platonic relationship?

First thing i noticed in myself is that i take too much pride in things. That keeps me faithful to my gf. I take real pride in that


Ryan share your thoughts and experience na
_______________________________________
Saiyan's Signature:

I'm Not Here
Reply With Quote
  #3 (permalink)  
 Old 12 Apr 08, 08:43 AM
FE RockStar
 
KingKrool is a distinguished student of fun college!KingKrool is a distinguished student of fun college!KingKrool is a distinguished student of fun college!KingKrool is a distinguished student of fun college!KingKrool is a distinguished student of fun college!
Rep Power: 5
Nickels: 7,107.69
Bank: 2,975.97
Default Re: Is it so difficult to have a platonic relationship?

What we really need is a statement from Agnel aka womanizer in chief of FE.
Reply With Quote
  #4 (permalink)  
 Old 12 Apr 08, 12:08 PM
Private Ryan's Avatar
The Boogieman
 
Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.Private Ryan is a board member of FE Fun College.
Rep Power: 31
Nickels: 117.86
Bank: 120,561.86
   
Default Re: Is it so difficult to have a platonic relationship?

I posted this topic for some serious discussion. Pls dont spam here, guys.. (Deleted spam posts.)

Well, I'm kind of divided on this topic, myself. Ideally speaking, it does seem possible, but in a real world scenario, its really hard to maintain a platonic relationship, especially when you are not really seeing someone else and same holds true for your friend who belongs to the opposite sex. Every relation starts with friendship which only keeps gaining a deeper meaning as time passes by and you get to know more about the other person. Then somewhere down the line , it really becomes hard to not start feeling for your friend the way you wud for your ideal life partner. Probably nature doesnt see a man woman relationship as a platonic one. Tht is why we start feeling this way. Its not about the physical desire. Atleast, i'm not talking in that context. That comes way later. But it has got more to do with the affection you develop for that person.So much so tht it really becomes hard to live without him/her. It becomes hard to let go. It becomes hard not to care for that friend. Physical desire is a secondary thing if you really love someone with all your heart and that person loves you as much in return. A love so pure that fleshly pleasures of this world cannot adulterate it. And when you start feeling this way, maintaining a platonic relationship is next to impossible.

In another scenario, if you are already seeing someone else and are dedicated, and yet you have a friend who belongs to the opposite sex, you can still maintain a platonic relationship with your friend given tht your friend doesnt want to interfere in your personal life too. But yes, our society is such tht people will always look at such a relationship with suspicion. I totally agree tht trust is the main foundation of any relationship. We human beings are vulnerable and we expect assurance in everything, even relationships. And there is no dearth of such people in this world who wud suspect their spouse of having an illegitimate relationship with a friend, while it may not be so. And that is the reason why maintaining a platonic relationship with a friend especially after marriage is very very hard. Your spouse will always be suspicious about your friendship. Ultimately, you give up on tht friendship to save the more serious relationships of your life and your family.

Finally, there is scenario of love gone wrong for some reason, maybe due to circumstances, that you dont feel like going thru the suffering again and yet, you dont want to give up on that person either. In that case, its best to maintain a friendly relationship with that person, without getting into the thick of the things again. You cud keep caring for tht person as a friend too. But expect nothing in return. Cos love is always based on expectations. WE want our loved ones to love us too. Same doesnt hold true for friendship. There is no binding on friends to love each other. There are no expectations. That is what probably qualifies to be called a platonic relationship..
_______________________________________
Private Ryan's Signature:


Last edited by Private Ryan; 12 Apr 08 at 12:28 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)  
 Old 12 Apr 08, 06:55 PM
magnetominge
 
chic_magnet is a lecturer at FE Fun College.chic_magnet is a lecturer at FE Fun College.chic_magnet is a lecturer at FE Fun College.chic_magnet is a lecturer at FE Fun College.chic_magnet is a lecturer at FE Fun College.chic_magnet is a lecturer at FE Fun College.chic_magnet is a lecturer at FE Fun College.
Send a message via MSN to chic_magnet Send a message via Yahoo to chic_magnet
Rep Power: 10
Nickels: 694.00
Bank: 248,928.53
Default Re: Is it so difficult to have a platonic relationship?

Ah platonic relationships.. have been hearing about that for quite some time now......
When your in love, or u have feelings for someone its quite hard to be just platonic. It is not hard when u have a friend whose a girl and to be platonic with her as long as you see her only as a friend and not as someone to derive physical pleasures from. Yes, it can get complicated at times but then its for each person to decide their limits. If physical needs are far greater than emotional needs then what is there to stop someone from being platonic??
I agree that society never sees a relationship between a man and woman as anything but platonic. But it is not for the society to decide how you should live your life and that means not giving up on someone too. Relationships are built on trust, if you cant be with someone whose trustworthy enough then they do not deserve to be with you.
Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)  
 Old 12 Apr 08, 07:16 PM
medpal's Avatar
Medic on call!!
 
medpal is a professor at FE Fun College.medpal is a professor at FE Fun College.medpal is a professor at FE Fun College.medpal is a professor at FE Fun College.medpal is a professor at FE Fun College.medpal is a professor at FE Fun College.medpal is a professor at FE Fun College.medpal is a professor at FE Fun College.medpal is a professor at FE Fun College.
Send a message via Yahoo to medpal
Rep Power: 14
Nickels: 8,485.38
Bank: 58,972.17
Default Re: Is it so difficult to have a platonic relationship?

Platonic Relationship.

I would love to be involved in one.

more later got some work to finish.
Reply With Quote
  #7 (permalink)  
 Old 15 Apr 08, 12:55 AM
Agnel's Avatar
Max, Nothing to lose
 
Award Medal
Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.
Rep Power: 34
Nickels: 1,108.58
Bank: 107,390.39
Default Re: Is it so difficult to have a platonic relationship?

Platonic relationships are possible only if both the parties involved think alike. But then if at one point of time if that friendship develops into love it is no more platonic, cos $ex is the only way you give show your intimate love (this is what i've read. I really can't understand how this and the reproduction cycle got mixed up)

The best thing is to maintain your distance and never break the boundaries!

If you have a platonic relationship which you can't tell it out in open, then it is not good to maintain that relationship either.
_______________________________________
Agnel's Signature:


Last edited by Agnel; 15 Apr 08 at 12:57 AM.
Reply With Quote
Reply


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Better Relationship Sandeep Jokers Club 4 21 Oct 07 03:27 PM
die hard 4 rating tomie89 Entertainment 1 28 Aug 07 05:56 AM
Why Video Games May Be Hard to Give Up dipdude Chit Chat 1 26 May 07 03:23 AM
Die Hard 4 Teaser Trailer dipdude Entertainment 2 21 Dec 06 01:56 AM

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On
Forum Jump

All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 03:46 AM.
Photo ShootsEmail ForwardsClean JokesIndia TravelSMS Jokes

Contact US |  FAQs
Privacy Policy |  Terms of Service |  Rules
About FunEnclave.com

FunEnclave is your gateway to fun and entertainment. A buzzing, clean and safe community that offers jokes, fun stuff, wallpapers, games, a discussion portal, fantasy leagues and a lot more.
Enjoy your stay and have Fun!
Copyright ©2008 FunEnclave.com, All Rights Reserved. Design © Private Ryan, For FunEnclave.
vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. LinkBacks Enabled by vBSEO © 2008, Crawlability, Inc.