NAVIGATION
USERPANEL & LOGIN
FE CONTENT ON EMAIL
Sponsors
|
 |
|
|
 |
Is this the team??This is a discussion on Is this the team?? within the Cricket Chat forums, part of the Sports Talk category; Today after much fan fair the selection committee has met in India and i dare say never before in India ...
|
|
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
|

20 Apr 07, 06:51 PM
 |
Admin
|
|
|
Rep Power: 44
Nickels: 35,413.00
Bank: 17,011.90
|
|
Is this the team??
Today after much fan fair the selection committee has met in India and i dare say never before in India did a more sham selection been done.
It was plain for all to see, those who saw the press conference.
1) BCCI appointing dravid as captain even before anyone met. It is indeed surprizing the amount of faith that is put on dravid. When its clear that the person is not a good captain and almost everyone agrees to that. Across the world the brunt of defeat is borne by the coach and captain. In India we have decorated two people who have failed us miserably at the grandest stage of them all.
2) Then you issue a directive to select a young team.(for both series) A board giving directives to its own selectors is indeed surprizing. You would have though that the selectors have sound mind to select the team. Or now since greg chapell says so, the board doesn't trust its own selectors.
3) And first time in history, we don't have a vice captain. It will be decided by the "captain and coach". My god, the silly process is not going to end. So now Mr Dravid, himself an incompetent captain will decide a chela VC. How many people trust dravid is an open question in the team and giving a VC power to him is an open invitation to him to select his own crony.
4) press asks the chairman of selector what happened to sachin and sourav? (he says they have been rested.) indeed? sourav rested. i thought he had plenty of rest already. If you want to drop someone, better say you dropped him. I think dravid himself is a fit candidate of being dropped anyway.
5) The people who have been dropped from ODI, i don't think it takes a genius to see that its the ODI that is their forte and not test cricket. If you wnated to retain them, it should have been in ODI.
6) And exactly who has been selected. Dinesh Mongia.. ahmm is he young? and exactly what has he done to win the place back. The people who did well in domestic cricket(like bose from bengal) don't find a place. Gautam Gambhir.. err..
By undermining the selectors, Indian cricket is going to move anywhere forward. Putting all faith on dravid and coach after a far from stellar record of his is nothing but foolishness. You don't play cricket for some "process" as dravid believes but to win. Winning is something he doesn't care too much about.
This is a regressive step all the way.
|

20 Apr 07, 08:08 PM
 |
Medic on call!!
|
|
|
Rep Power: 14
Nickels: 8,542.38
Bank: 62,581.74
|
|
Re: Is this the team??
i am also disappointed with the cosmetic changes they have done.
it tendulkar and ganguly can be rested why not sehwag and yuvraj.
even test team does not show anything spectacular looks like board and selectors did some arrangements with players and exchanged places.
lame.
|

20 Apr 07, 09:38 PM
|
FE Fanatic
|
|
|
Rep Power: 22
Nickels: 6,873.70
Bank: 1,729.62
|
|
Re: Is this the team??
After all this India can safely put their claim as World's No.1 BANANA cricketing Country
...OMG..what a Selection  .Only GOD save India...
***loss of words*** 
|

21 Apr 07, 08:53 PM
 |
Trailblazer
|
|
|
Rep Power: 28
Nickels: 1,713.27
Bank: 770,605.86
|
|
Re: Is this the team??
I am wondering what will happen happen when we travel to australia with this team l8r this year. Getting goosebumps, Already!!
|

21 Apr 07, 09:18 PM
|
FE RockStar
|
|
|
Rep Power: 3
Nickels: 9,761.52
Bank: 824.24
|
|
Re: Is this the team??
Safin , Dravid will continue performing as a good batsman he has always been .. I dont think he should be stripped of his captaincy .. even the team doesn't look good . every time , there has been some controversy or the other . this team will never look good (but only on paper) as far as I'm concerned .
|

21 Apr 07, 09:58 PM
 |
Trailblazer
|
|
|
Rep Power: 28
Nickels: 1,713.27
Bank: 770,605.86
|
|
Re: Is this the team??
^ Oh boy, I must say, you are a real optimist 
|

21 Apr 07, 10:04 PM
 |
I'M BACK!!! :D
|
|
|
Rep Power: 11
Nickels: 11,291.80
Bank: 6,916.05
|
|
Re: Is this the team??
can anyone pls post the whole team here? kinda confusing :s
|

21 Apr 07, 10:15 PM
 |
Live Your Dream
|
|
|
Rep Power: 28
Nickels: 1,069.60
Bank: 65,362.31
|
|
Re: Is this the team??
I think d team is Fine ..... Youngsters should be given a chance .... Great to see Kaif back in d side .... the only problem i have is with Gangully being rested ... i mean d guy is ur best batsmen currently ... y rest him ?? 
|

21 Apr 07, 10:31 PM
|
FE Fanatic
|
|
|
Rep Power: 22
Nickels: 6,873.70
Bank: 1,729.62
|
|
Re: Is this the team??
^^ just the question which amazes everybody undermining all sanity & cricketing logic!
I say....bloody politics once again raising its UGLY heads.Alas,its here Long 2 stay with BCCI & India!
|

22 Apr 07, 04:56 PM
 |
Trailblazer
|
|
|
Rep Power: 28
Nickels: 1,713.27
Bank: 770,605.86
|
|
Re: Is this the team??
can anyone pls post the whole team here? kinda confusing :s
ODI squad:
Rahul Dravid (capt),
Gautam Gambhir,
Robin Uthappa,
Virender Sehwag,
Yuvraj Singh,
Mahendra Singh Dhoni,
Dinesh Karthik,
Manoj Tiwary,
S Sreesanth,
Munaf Patel,
Zaheer Khan,
Rudra Pratap Singh,
Piyush Chawla,
Ramesh Powar
Dinesh Mongia.
Test squad:
Rahul Dravid (capt),
Wasim Jaffer,
Sachin Tendulkar,
VVS Laxman,
Mahendra Singh Dhoni,
Sourav Ganguly,
Yuvraj Singh,
Dinesh Karthik,
S Sreesanth,
Zaheer Khan,
Vikram Raj Vir Singh,
Munaf Patel,
Anil Kumble,
Ramesh Powar
Rajesh Pawar
|
 |
|
|