FunEnclave
 
Search 






Not a member?
Register now!



Iphone alternatives, competition and Rival phones

This is a discussion on Iphone alternatives, competition and Rival phones within the Mobile Mania forums, part of the The Lounge category; Iphone rival phones and what to buy if you can't buy an iphone? Basically am looking for one now so ...

Reply
> The Lounge > Mobile Mania
  #1 (permalink)  
 Old 23 Aug 08, 11:27 PM
Safin's Avatar
Admin
 
Award Medal
Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!
Rep Power: 47
Nickels: 44,966.00
Bank: 27,909.83
     
Thumbs Up Iphone alternatives, competition and Rival phones


Iphone rival phones and what to buy if you can't buy an iphone?


Basically am looking for one now so i might as well list all the information here to benefit someone else. Everything is from different sources and might have been reworded for clarity.

Current Iphone Killers (rivals)
Blackberry Bold
Samsung Omnia
Nokia N96
HTC Diamond/Touch?

(Any Others? HTC Touch, N95)

Here is a nice article on where iphone fails over its competition, and what are the obvious replacements for the iphone



STORAGE

3G iPhone comes in 8GB and 16GB models, and with no expandable memory. While its rivals, Nokia N96 and Samsung Omnia offer higher storage.

Nokia N96 offers memory expansion of up to 24GB. This smartphone packs 16GB of internal memory, which is expandable up to 24GB.

According to Nokia, the phone can store up to 60 hours of video or 20 full-length movies. The 24GB N96 can store up to 18000 songs and up to 20000 images.

Similarly, the Samsung Omina has same storage variants, 8GB and 16 GB, and it also allows users to expand memory.

CAMERA

In the days when 5-7 megapixel camera seems to have become a rule, Apple iPhone's 2 megapixel seems pale. Its closest rival, Nokia N96 boasts of 5 megapixel camera with Carl Zeiss optics, dual LED flash and video light. The video camera captures at 30 frames per second.

Not only this, N96 predecessor N95 also boasted of a 5 megapixel camera with Carl Zeiss autofocus lens. It has support for multiple scene bright flash, high quality VGA video recording at up to 30 fps and front-facing VGA camera for video calling.

However, missing features like video recording and optical zoom in iPhone only add insult to injury.

Samsung's iPhone wannabe Omnia too features a 5 megapixel camera. It supports auto focus, image stabliser, auto-panorama shot, wide dynamic range and face detection options.

It also supports video recording, video editing and audio and live dubbing.

The latest touchscreen smartphone from BlackBerry, Bold, though has a 2 megapixel camera, but support video recording, built-in flash and digital zoom, unlike iPhone.

HTC's Touch Diamond too has high-resolution camera (3.2 megapixel) with an optical auto-focus lens, video calling capability and auto sensor screen pivoting.

Like HTC's smartphone, Sony Ericsson’s XPERIA X1 too has a 3.2 megapixel camera with photo light. The phone is company's answer to Apple iPhone.


MULTIMEDIA FEATURES

Another feature where Nokia's 'Killer Product' steals a march over iPhone. For music lovers, Nokia N96 has media keys, 3.5 mm headphone connector and built-in 3D stereo speakers. Users can access digital video broadcasting, wireless Internet and Bluetooth.

To engage gaming enthusiasts, there are N-gage games. Nokia N96 has support for stereo Bluetooth (A2DP), but iPhone lacks this.

Samsung Omnia too stands high on multimedia features with a TV-Out feature to playback content from the phone directly on the television screen. DivX technology enables video content transfer from the PC to the mobile.

Not just this, Apple iPhone also doesn't let users transfer data using Bluetooth and lacks regular FM and offers users streaming Internet radio. Users can only use the Bluetooth feature in iPhone for hands-free calling.

Another area where iPhone lags behind is no MMS and message forward. Users cannot simply forward text messages. Users can only send text messages or snapshots via email. Also, there is no option to send SMS to multiple contacts.

Also, while the iPhone offers the popular Google maps, the drawback is that these maps do not offer voice directions in India. The N96 offers Nokia Maps 2.0 with voice directions for India as well.

Even BlackBerry Bold boasts of high-end multimedia features. For music and video, the BlackBerry Desktop Manager software includes Roxio Media Manager as well as Roxio Photosuite 9 LE, to edit pictures and create photo albums on the computer.

NO OPERATOR LOCK

One of the biggest plus points of iPhone rivals is that they are service provider agnostic. As a user, you need not get tied to Airtel for certain period with a certain rental plan just to own them.

Most iPhone rivals, including Omnia, N96 and BlackBerry Bold can be bought off the shelves with no operator bar.

Unlike, iPhone for which you need to switch to Airtel or Vodafone in India. Can be an issue, in these days of no number portability.
COST

Another point which can go in the iPhone rival's favour is the pricing.

You may buy an above Rs 30K iPhone rival, but after that you may keep your prepaid plan running on it, costing you not more than Rs 200 a month. This means no compulsory monthly mobile bill for you. This is especially useful for users who buy a phone more for its features than just calling.

However, iPhone comes bundled with a service provider's rental plan which is likely to be fixed for a certain period.

So, iPhone rivals may be priced at par with iPhone or slightly above, but may actually have lower running costs. For instance, AT&T users in US can buy the 8GB iPhone, for $199 (equivalent to Rs 8,500) with a 2-year contract.

BATTERY


Another area where iPhone struggles to compete with rivals is no user replaceable battery. Users cannot change an iPhone battery on their own. They will have to send it to an Apple outlet for this. On the other hand, Nokia N96 offers users the freedom to remove and replace the battery.

Though Apple reportedly claims that it has intentionally left out the user-replaceable battery because it adds bulk and weight, but users may not wish to buy that reason.

However, it’s rival BlackBerry’s Bold that supports removable/rechargeable battery which provides multi-hour usage with a target talktime of approximately 5 hours and standby time of 13 days.

Unlike Apple iPhone, Samsung Omnia supports a removable battery.

The Specs:
Iphone 3G




Nokia N96




Samsung Omnia




HTC Diamond





BlackBerry Bold





Reviews
iPhone 3G review: Twice the hype, half the novelty - GSMArena.com
Samsung i900 Omnia review: The whole nine yards - GSMArena.com
HTC Touch Diamond review: Geek's best friend - GSMArena.com
Nokia N96 Video Review - Mobile Phones - CNET Asia

Head to Head
HTC Touch Diamond vs. Samsung i900 Omnia: Head-to-Head - GSMArena.com
----------------------------------------------
Reply With Quote
  #2 (permalink)  
 Old 24 Aug 08, 06:37 PM
FE Addict
 
sanjuro is applying for fun college!
Rep Power: 1
Nickels: 1,128.58
Bank: 0.00
Default Re: Iphone alternatives, competition and Rival phones

there is no iphone killer period

iphone is revolutionary in its design, most importantly interface. Even before using an iphone, I have been an apple user for years. apple's intuitive user interface is what wins it over everyone else. agreed, that the pricing in india is ridiculous. you may want to wait for the price to come down. but, imo, don't spend 20k, 30k on any of the other above phones... unless your company pays for it...
Reply With Quote
  #3 (permalink)  
 Old 24 Aug 08, 09:16 PM
Dammit's Avatar
FE TrendSetter
 
Dammit is a lecturer at FE Fun College.Dammit is a lecturer at FE Fun College.Dammit is a lecturer at FE Fun College.Dammit is a lecturer at FE Fun College.Dammit is a lecturer at FE Fun College.Dammit is a lecturer at FE Fun College.Dammit is a lecturer at FE Fun College.Dammit is a lecturer at FE Fun College.
Rep Power: 10
Nickels: 2,371.31
Bank: 30,474.86
  
Default Re: Iphone alternatives, competition and Rival phones

The Only thing i like about the iPhone is the User Interface....
Other features i don't like...
So I am not Buying one...
Reply With Quote
  #4 (permalink)  
 Old 25 Aug 08, 08:50 PM
xXx's Avatar
xXx xXx is offline
{Secret Agent}
 
Award Medal
xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.
Rep Power: 45
Nickels: 1,262.00
Bank: 84,475.10
   
Default Re: Iphone alternatives, competition and Rival phones

I am gonna buy Samsung Omnia i900 chkd it out on GSM arena......
its sounds like a gr8 phone to me.....will buy a 8gb one
Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)  
 Old 25 Aug 08, 08:56 PM
Ninja's Avatar
Trailblazer
 
Ninja has numerous fun patents to his name.Ninja has numerous fun patents to his name.Ninja has numerous fun patents to his name.Ninja has numerous fun patents to his name.Ninja has numerous fun patents to his name.Ninja has numerous fun patents to his name.Ninja has numerous fun patents to his name.Ninja has numerous fun patents to his name.Ninja has numerous fun patents to his name.Ninja has numerous fun patents to his name.Ninja has numerous fun patents to his name.Ninja has numerous fun patents to his name.
Rep Power: 29
Nickels: 1,555.47
Bank: 1,339,282.50
   
Default Re: Iphone alternatives, competition and Rival phones

Its foolish to buy the 3G phones now. Apart from the high costs, the users can't use all the features.

I will wait for 3G to be implemented in India, till then i am happy with my GSM phone
Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)  
 Old 25 Aug 08, 09:02 PM
Agnel's Avatar
Super Bark
 
Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.Agnel is a board member of FE Fun College.
Rep Power: 38
Nickels: 1,138.22
Bank: 202,732.69
 
Default Re: Iphone alternatives, competition and Rival phones

Originally Posted by Ninja View Post
Its foolish to buy the 3G phones now. Apart from the high costs, the users can't use all the features.

I will wait for 3G to be implemented in India, till then i am happy with my GSM phone
well said
THe networks here aren't well equipped to handle 3g traffic yet

So wait for another 3-4 years
_______________________________________
Agnel's Signature:

Reply With Quote
  #7 (permalink)  
 Old 25 Aug 08, 09:03 PM
Safin's Avatar
Admin
 
Award Medal
Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!Safin is Director of FE Fun College!
Rep Power: 47
Nickels: 44,966.00
Bank: 27,909.83
     
Default Re: Iphone alternatives, competition and Rival phones

Originally Posted by xXx View Post
I am gonna buy Samsung Omnia i900 chkd it out on GSM arena......
its sounds like a gr8 phone to me.....will buy a 8gb one
Its great phone in all areas other than the resolution.
Thats antique
Reply With Quote
  #8 (permalink)  
 Old 29 Aug 08, 01:30 AM
xXx's Avatar
xXx xXx is offline
{Secret Agent}
 
Award Medal
xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.xXx is a board member of FE Fun College.
Rep Power: 45
Nickels: 1,262.00
Bank: 84,475.10
   
Default Re: Iphone alternatives, competition and Rival phones

yeah...re but wanted to buy a touch screen since ages....waiting for a phone...to have everythin in it...i'll have to compromise on something....so resolution be it...I am as it is using an N95...with same resolution now...
Reply With Quote
  #9 (permalink)  
 Old 5 Sep 08, 02:55 PM